Thursday, January 28, 2021
Literary Reviews
  • Home
  • OUR BOOK SHOP
    • Erotic Novels
    • BEST SELLING BOOKS
    • Science Fiction Books
    • Business and Management
    • Computing and IT
    • Cooking
    • Education
    • Religion & Spirituality
    • Self Help
    • Teens & Young Adults
  • Literary Review
  • Literature
  • Book Writing
  • Kindle Publishing
  • Romantic
  • Science Fiction
  • Cooking
  • MORE
    • Erotic
    • Mysteries, Thrillers
    • Literary Themes
    • Business and Management
    • Literary Agents
    • Literary Devices
    • New Books
    • Self Help
    • Teens & Young Adults Novels
    • Computing and IT
    • Education
    • Religion & Spirituality Novels
No Result
View All Result
Literary Reviews
Home Kindle Publishing

Young adult novel “We Are Not Free” tells a compelling story of 14 Japanese American teenagers in wartime incarceration

admin by admin
September 11, 2020
in Kindle Publishing
0
Young adult novel “We Are Not Free” tells a compelling story of 14 Japanese American teenagers in wartime incarceration
0
SHARES
1
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter


In the young adult novel We Are Not Free, Yonsei writer Traci Chee follows 14 Nisei teenagers, mostly from San Francisco Japantown, through their wartime incarceration. It’s a daring project; the characters hand off the epic story as if it were a relay baton, each picking up the plot where the last one left off. The result is an emotionally nuanced though historically puzzling book which will appeal to contemporary young adult readers.

A New York Times-bestselling author of books for young adults, Chee’s strengths are particularly highlighted in the novel’s emotional resonance. As a somewhat emotionally reticent generation, not many narratives about the incarceration dive so deeply into the emotions of Nisei teens: fear and resistance to racist bullying, adolescent love and heartbreak, rebellion against parents and authorities, anguish at family separation.  Much of the time, these portraits will feel relevant and relatable for contemporary adolescent readers.

Chee’s sensitivity to multiple viewpoints and positions is also one of the novel’s highlights. Most admirably, the narrative resists placing military service in direct opposition to the narratives of resistance (No-No’s, hunger strikers, renunciants, repatriates). The novel also covers more than one camp (Topaz, Tule Lake). In particular, its detailed attention to Tule Lake covers material that’s rarely been seen in young adult books: the stockade, the bullpen, as well as the use of organized resistance such as hunger strikes. The characters who volunteer for the 442nd military regiment are also given sympathetic and detailed treatment.

Ambitiously, Chee’s novel follows 14 points of view, some in more depth than others. The strength of this approach is that it allows for a greater number of narratives (“only a fraction of the 120,000,” as the author acknowledges in the Afterword). Stories of issues like the loyalty questionnaire and registration crisis are more complex.  However, a risk with this approach is that it’s difficult to track which voice is speaking, even with the help of the “Registry” provided at the beginning of the book and the individual character names and ages at the beginning of each chapter. The difference between the voices doesn’t read as distinctly as it might, and the relationships between the characters (some are siblings, some are not) is also difficult to remember.

In several cases, the historical choices that the novel makes are harder to understand. The real names and circumstances of historical figures such as Dillon Meyer and Mike Masaoka are used, but the names of Japanese Americans who were incarcerated are not. Several historical figures have their names changed: James Wakasa, the Issei man who was infamously shot by a guard at Topaz;  Koji Todoroki, Tom Kobayashi, and Tokio Yamane, the Nisei men who were beaten with a baseball bat in the Tule Lake stockade are not named, but the infamous baseball bat is used in a situation involving several of the book’s main fictional characters. In a novel that pays so much attention to historical circumstances, it’s hard to know why the names of these men and their histories would be altered, rather than brought to light and remembered.

Other, smaller historical choices are similarly difficult to understand. At times, the novel veers into a contemporary writing style which rings less true for readers familiar with Nisei voices. (“THINGS I’M HOLDING ONTO: My anger,” writes one character in a chapter with similar lists.) Also, one of the characters is nicknamed “Yum-Yum,” perhaps a play on her Japanese last name, “Oishi” (oishii is Japanese for delicious). It’s hard to separate this cringeworthy name from Gilbert and Sullivan’s operetta The Mikado, and harder to understand the reasons for its selection among the many other Americanized Nisei nicknames available.  

Finally, the frequent use of the word “keto” (Japanese racial slur for White people) may strike a jarring note, as it’s more widely used in immediate moments of anger than in passing references (“hakujin” seems to be more widely used). In an advance copy of the book, Chee notes that she uses racial slurs to highlight the racial animosity of the times, but does not specify which words are slurs, which can add to greater confusion.

Overall, I’m conflicted—the author’s ability to capture emotional resonance is skillful and will help bring Nisei teens to contemporary teens—but several of the historical choices prevent me from wholeheartedly endorsing the book.

For more arts, click here



Related posts

Why (and How) Amazon Created the Kindle and Changed the Book Industry Forever

Why (and How) Amazon Created the Kindle and Changed the Book Industry Forever

January 27, 2021
London, Ont. teen who worked at long-term care home dies after COVID-19 diagnosis

London, Ont. teen who worked at long-term care home dies after COVID-19 diagnosis

January 24, 2021
Tags: adultAmericanCompellingFreeincarcerationJapaneseStoryteenagerstellswartimeyoung
Previous Post

Islanders Anxiety - Episode 130 - Bad Place in a Good Place

Next Post

Leveraging brain power, computing, biomedical assets to battle COVID-19 - UB Now: News and views for UB faculty and staff

Next Post
Leveraging brain power, computing, biomedical assets to battle COVID-19 – UB Now: News and views for UB faculty and staff

Leveraging brain power, computing, biomedical assets to battle COVID-19 - UB Now: News and views for UB faculty and staff

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

RECOMMENDED NEWS

How to self-publish a Kindle eBook at home

How to self-publish a Kindle eBook at home

7 months ago
Emirates Literature Foundation partners with Google to promote Arab authors – News

Emirates Literature Foundation partners with Google to promote Arab authors – News

1 month ago
UNM professor’s book a semi finalist for Portuguese literary prize : UNM Newsroom

UNM professor’s book a semi finalist for Portuguese literary prize : UNM Newsroom

5 months ago
Stormzy Book Venture Helps Writer Win Prestigious Prize

Stormzy Book Venture Helps Writer Win Prestigious Prize

6 months ago

Products

  • Girl, Missing: The top-ten bestselling thriller (Volume 1) £5.99
  • The Power of Now: A Guide to Spiritual Enlightenment: (20th Anniversary Edition) £7.99
  • Cooking for Family and Friends: 100 Lean Recipes to Enjoy Together £12.99
  • Made in India: 130 Simple, Fresh and Flavourful Recipes from One Indian Family £13.49
  • One Of Us Is Lying £6.30

BROWSE BY CATEGORIES

  • Book Writing
  • Business and Management
  • Computing and IT
  • Cooking Books
  • Education
  • Erotic
  • Kindle Publishing
  • Literary Agents
  • Literary Devices
  • Literary Review
  • Literary Themes
  • Literature
  • Mysteries, Thrillers & Suspense
  • New Books
  • Religion & Spirituality
  • Romantic Novels
  • Science Fiction
  • Self Help

RELATED PRODUCTS

  • National 5 Business Management (Bright Red Study Guide) (BrightRED Study Guides) £12.99
  • Twochubbycubs The Cookbook: 100 Tried and Tested Slimming Recipes £8.00
  • First Phonics Ages 3-4: Reception English Home Learning and School Resources from the Publisher of Revision Practice… £2.18
  • The World Sauces Cookbook: 60 Regional Recipes and 30 Perfect Pairings £12.51
  • Awakening Spirits: A Native American Path to Inner Peace, Healing, and Spiritual Growth (Religion and Spirituality) £10.27

PRODUCT CATEGORIES

  • Best Selling Books
  • Erotic
  • Science Fiction Books
  • Cooking
  • Business and Management
  • Education
  • Computing and IT
  • Religion & Spirituality
  • Teens & Young Adults
  • Self Help
  • Mysteries, Thrillers & Suspense
  • Romance Books
Literary Reviews

Follow us on social media:

Recent News

  • How Female Writers Have Changed The Comic Book Industry
  • New Book From Author Arnobio Morelix Outlines Post-Pandemic Path to Recovery for Entrepreneurs, Tech Companies
  • 10 Best Romantic Dramas Of The 1990s (Ranked By Metacritic)

Category

  • Book Writing
  • Business and Management
  • Computing and IT
  • Cooking Books
  • Education
  • Erotic
  • Kindle Publishing
  • Literary Agents
  • Literary Devices
  • Literary Review
  • Literary Themes
  • Literature
  • Mysteries, Thrillers & Suspense
  • New Books
  • Religion & Spirituality
  • Romantic Novels
  • Science Fiction
  • Self Help

Recent News

How Female Writers Have Changed The Comic Book Industry

How Female Writers Have Changed The Comic Book Industry

January 28, 2021
New Book From Author Arnobio Morelix Outlines Post-Pandemic Path to Recovery for Entrepreneurs, Tech Companies

New Book From Author Arnobio Morelix Outlines Post-Pandemic Path to Recovery for Entrepreneurs, Tech Companies

January 28, 2021
  • Home
  • OUR BOOK SHOP
  • Literary Review
  • Literature
  • Book Writing
  • Kindle Publishing
  • Romantic
  • Science Fiction
  • Cooking
  • MORE

© 2020 literaryreviews

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • OUR BOOK SHOP
    • Erotic Novels
    • BEST SELLING BOOKS
    • Science Fiction Books
    • Business and Management
    • Computing and IT
    • Cooking
    • Education
    • Religion & Spirituality
    • Self Help
    • Teens & Young Adults
  • Literary Review
  • Literature
  • Book Writing
  • Kindle Publishing
  • Romantic
  • Science Fiction
  • Cooking
  • MORE
    • Erotic
    • Mysteries, Thrillers
    • Literary Themes
    • Business and Management
    • Literary Agents
    • Literary Devices
    • New Books
    • Self Help
    • Teens & Young Adults Novels
    • Computing and IT
    • Education
    • Religion & Spirituality Novels

© 2020 literaryreviews

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Fill the forms bellow to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In